The essentials of this article
  • When it is operated: significant or progressive neurological deficit, cauda equina (an emergency) or disabling sciatica persisting despite good conservative treatment.
  • First question: does the herniation on your MRI explain your sciatica? Many people without symptoms have herniations.
  • Technique: microdiscectomy is the most established; fusion is not automatic.
  • First surgery or reoperation: they are evaluated differently; Dr. Ávila treats both.
  • Urgent: progressive weakness, loss of sphincter control or groin numbness.

01When is a lumbar disc herniation operated on?

A lumbar disc herniation is very common, and most people who have one do not need surgery: with time and appropriate treatment, sciatica usually improves (Benoist, 2002; Casey, 2011). Surgery is considered when the herniation compresses a nerve root, that compression explains the symptoms, and the picture meets one of these criteria (Kreiner et al., 2014; Berry et al., 2019):

1. Significant or worsening neurological weakness (for example, difficulty lifting the foot).
2. Disabling leg pain that persists after a reasonable period of well-indicated conservative treatment.
3. Cauda equina syndrome —numbness in the groin, difficulty urinating or having a bowel movement— which is an emergency and cannot wait.

Key fact

An MRI showing a herniation is not enough to justify surgery. What decides surgery is that the herniation explains your symptoms and that your situation warrants intervening.

Do you have an MRI showing a lumbar disc herniation and sciatica?

Request an evaluation

It is the first question the specialist must answer, and the answer is not always yes. Many people without symptoms have herniations or protrusions on MRI (Weishaupt et al., 1998), and several conditions —hip, deep gluteal pain, neuropathy, stenosis— can produce pain similar to sciatica (Tarulli & Raynor, 2007).

That is why the decision combines three things: the level and side of the herniation on imaging, the pattern of pain, weakness and reflexes on examination, and, when in doubt, studies such as electromyography (Coster et al., 2010; Tawa et al., 2016). When all three agree, the indication is much stronger.

The most established procedure for a lumbar herniation compressing a root is microdiscectomy: through a small incision and with a microscope, the herniated fragment compressing the nerve is removed while the rest of the disc is preserved. Dr. Ávila performs it as part of his minimally invasive practice. Other techniques exist, such as endoscopic discectomy, and the choice depends on the level, the type of herniation, the anatomy and the surgeon’s experience with each technique (Kreiner et al., 2014).

A fusion with screws is not an automatic part of operating on a herniation. It is reserved for cases with instability, spondylolisthesis or a reoperation in which stabilization is needed. Asking which technique is proposed, why, and what the alternative is, is part of a good consultation.

Waiting is a reasonable option when there is no progressive neurological deficit or warning signs. Guidelines propose staged treatment —education, activity within tolerance, physical therapy, short-term medication and, in selected patients, epidural injections— before deciding on surgery (Stochkendahl et al., 2018; Kreiner et al., 2014).

In a randomized trial of persistent sciatica, some patients improved with manipulation without surgery, while microdiscectomy gave greater relief in those who needed it (McMorland et al., 2010). The decision to wait or to operate is shared and should be revisited if the picture changes.

Every spine surgery carries risks —bleeding, infection, injury to the dura or nerve, and pain that does not fully improve— which the surgeon should explain clearly for your case. Some patients keep symptoms after surgery, or develop a recurrent herniation, fibrosis or residual stenosis, and each situation is managed differently (Rogerson et al., 2019).

On recovery, a systematic review found that the large majority of patients return to work after surgery for lumbar radiculopathy, although the timing depends on the type of job and personal factors (Huysmans et al., 2018). The rehabilitation and return-to-activity plan is defined with you before surgery.

Yes, and that is why Dr. Ávila treats both scenarios. A first herniation surgery and a reoperation are not evaluated the same way:

First surgeryReoperation
Key questionDoes the herniation explain the sciatica and did conservative treatment fail?Is it a recurrent herniation, a new level, fibrosis or canal narrowing?
AnatomyNo previous surgeryScar tissue and adhesions around the nerves
What is reviewedMRI (images, not just the report) and examinationCurrent and previous MRI, plus the first surgery report
FusionNot automaticNot automatic; depends on stability and cause

A high percentage of the patients Dr. Ávila operates on have previously been operated on by another surgeon; he also performs primary procedures, such as microdiscectomy and minimally invasive decompression.

These are the questions worth asking any spine surgeon, including the one proposing surgery:

• Does the MRI show nerve compression that matches my symptoms?
• How likely is surgery to relieve my leg pain?
• Which technique do you recommend and why? Is there an alternative?
• Which risks, recurrence and recovery time should I expect?
• What happens if I decide to wait or continue conservative treatment?

Bring the MRI images (not just the report), previous studies, a summary of the treatments you have already tried and, if you were operated on before, that surgery’s report. Seek urgent care if you develop progressive weakness of the leg or foot, loss of bladder or bowel control, or numbness in the groin.

Opioid-free

Since July 2026, we no longer use opioids in the postoperative pain management of our patients.

A final reflection

Operating on a lumbar disc herniation can substantially relieve sciatica when the indication is right: a herniation compressing the root that explains the symptoms, in a patient whose situation justifies intervening. When the indication is not solid, surgery may not help and adds risks.

That is why the evaluation should be done by a spine specialist who reviews your images, examination and history together, and who is clear about alternatives, risks and what to expect. The decision should not be rushed: a good diagnosis is what decides whether you need surgery.